The Court of Justice of the EU recently dealt with codetermination rights in the context of multinational companies governed by national law, and of European companies established by transformation - subjected to the safeguards of the SE Directive. According to this EU jurisprudence, Members States can decide on the territorial or extra-territorial scope of application of their national participation system without necessarily breaching EU free movement and anti-discrimination rules. Also, European companies set by transformation must safeguard all the components of the national participation system previously applicable to the company, which may concern trade union nomination and reservation of seats and other procedural elements.
This section also collects selected national case law with relevance for Board-level Employee Representation rights and their national application with transnational implications.
European Court of Justice (ECJ) Case C-566/15 Erzberger v TUI AG
ETUI commentaries
- Lafuente Hernández, S. and Rasnača, Z. (2019). Can workers’ rights ever catch up? The Erzberger case and EU cross-border reality. Industrial Law Journal, 48(1): 98–116, https://doi.org/10.1093/indlaw/dwy025
- Lafuente Hernández, S. (2017). ECJ upholds German codetermination rights, but misses an opportunity. (July 2017) in www.workers-participation.eu
- Lafuente Hernández, S. (2017). German codetermination compatible with EU law, states Advocate General while calling for more inclusiveness. (May 2017) in www. workers-participation.eu
- Other commentaries
European Court of Justice (ECJ) Case C-677/20 IGMetall and ver.di vs SAP SE
- German Bundesarbeitsgericht (BAG) Request preliminary ruling
- Opinion AG
- ECJ judgement
- German BAG judgement
ETUI commentaries
- [under construction]
- Other commentaries
French court cases related to the interpretation of ‘cumul des mandats’
French Courts have interpreted some of the effects of article L225-30 of the French Commercial Code on the cumul de mandats.
- French Cour de Cassation, Chambre Sociale, 30 September 2005, 04-10.490 Judgement
- Tribunal d’instance de Courbevoie, 6 March 2017, n° 11-16-000911, Fédération CGT des sociétés d’études C/SAP France Holding SA Judgement